On paper, the 1st team's season was pretty successful. In the trophy cabinet it was less so, and in the cold, hard bitten world we call reality, the jury is still out.
Firstly the trophy cabinet, the easiest part of the season to quantify. Nada. There will be room for the Minor Cup, and the Division 3 trophy, as well as assorted bowls, tennis, squash and table tennis trophies. There were a few close ones though. Runners up in Division 2, runners up in the Alan Murray 20/20, quarter finalists in the Irish Senior Cup (and defeated by the eventual winners
Waringstown), and somehow defeated to the eventual winners
Merrion in the
Leinster Senior Cup. So not to be sniffed at, but disappointing anyway.
When looked at in detail, the season throws up more questions than it answers. That last match loss to
Terenure was galling, less in the result, than in the fact that so little fight was put up. It appeared not to matter. Individually there were plenty of good performances, tempered somewhat by the fact that Division 2 is not Division 1 (in fact it's hardly Division 2).
In all cricket, six batsmen scored over 250 runs, all at an average of over 30. The sextet were Mark Jones (712 at 30.96), Anton
Scholtz (605 at 33.61), Craig
Mallon (541 at 36.07), JP
O'Dwyer (426 at 30.43),
Zac Curtis (329 at 32.9) and Joey Carroll (285 at 31.67). Corey Edwards was the other heavy scorer, 349 at 24.93. Decent performances, and with a couple more big knocks, it's possible that the season would have been a glorious success. There were no hundreds scored, but one in the last match against
Terenure, the Alan Murray final, and maybe one against
Waringstown, and the trophy cabinet would have been groaning. If, if, if.
The bowling told a similar tale to the batting, with five players taking most of the wickets, all at decent averages. Corey Edwards came top with 43 wickets at 16.28, but Peter Byrne grabbed the headlines with 14.26. Anton
Scholtz, Joey Carroll and Will Lennon were the other three.
So what's not to praise? The squad was small, and the feeling is that without players in depth, Division 1 could be a struggle. Hugh McDonnell, Gareth
Delany and Sunny
Faizan aside, youth isn't exactly on the team's side (the youth quotient was 2.9% the lowest of the seven sides). But hey, we're back in Division 1, and it seems that the quality in the top Division is lower than it was in 2010. A few judicious signings and anything is possible.
In the all time Senior stats, Mark Jones moved up to 3rd with 7143 runs., overtaking Joe Byrne in the process. JP
O'Dwyer moved up three places to 18th with 3272 runs (overtaking
Mssrs Caprani,
Marchant and
Ganly in the process). Anton
Scholtx moved up to 26th with 2505 senior runs, Will Lennon to 33rd with 1737, Craig
Mallon to 36th with 1622 and David Lucas moved from 41st to 40th, overtaking Joe Byrne
snr in the process.
Looking at the bowlers, Peter Byrne passed Paddy Boland, to move from 14th to 13th with 230 wickets at 21.23 and Will Lennon moved from 19th to 17th, and now has 192 wickets.
Top batsmen - Mark Jones
Top bowler - Corey Edwards
Youth quotient (%age of matches played that were youth players) - 2.9%,
If the 1sts were a team at the RWC 2011, they'd be - Ireland. Did OK apart from a bad result at the end. But what now for the Golden Generation? Is there anything left in the tank?